Uncategorized

What are bad or toxic backlinks?

Wat zijn slechte of toxische backlinks?

Bad or toxic backlinks are links to your website that are artificial, misleading, or mainly created to influence search results. The word toxic comes mostly from SEO tools. Google usually talks about link spam, unnatural links, and link schemes. So an unknown or small website that links to you on its own is not automatically dangerous.

That is why you should not look only at a red score in a tool. Check who made the link, why it is there, and whether payment, exchange, or automation was involved. In most cases, Google can decide for itself which links it trusts and which it does not. The disavow tool is meant only for special situations. Using it the wrong way can actually cause harm.

A backlink is a link from another website to your website. A natural backlink happens when someone finds your page useful and refers to it voluntarily. A bad backlink is made on purpose to make a search engine think a website is more popular than it really is.

Google describes link spam as creating links to or from a website with the main goal of manipulating search results. This can include paid links, large-scale link exchanges, automated link services, and paid articles without the proper link label.

Why is the word toxic confusing?

SEO tools use their own models to judge backlinks. For example, they look at the topic, link pattern, number of outgoing links, or the estimated quality of a domain. Such a score can be a useful starting point for research. But it is not Google’s judgment, and it is not proof that a link is harming your website.

A new and small blog may have a low score, but still give a real and relevant recommendation. A large and well-known domain may place a paid link that breaks the rules. So always look at the context, the intent, and how the link came to be.

Which backlinks need extra attention?

  • Links that you or a previous SEO agency bought to improve rankings.
  • Large numbers of links from automated networks.
  • Excessive link exchanges without a real editorial reason.
  • Links in paid articles without rel sponsored or nofollow where that is needed.
  • Links on low-quality pages that exist only to place links.
  • Repeated links with the exact same commercial anchor text.
  • Links from hacked pages, hidden text, or misleading widgets.

No single feature proves there is a problem. A website may simply use your brand name often by coincidence. A partner may logically refer to the same tool from several pages. That is why you should always assess the full pattern.

Which links are usually not a reason to panic?

Over time, every website gets strange links. Scrapers copy pages. Automatic roundups mention domains. Sometimes foreign websites link to your page without clear context. Google says most websites do not need the disavow tool. Google can usually judge for itself which links it should trust and which it should not.

So do not create a big disavow file every month based only on a tool score. Focus on links you arranged yourself, or links that clearly form part of an artificial pattern.

Google uses links to discover pages. Links are also one of the signals Google uses to understand relevance and popularity. That makes links attractive for manipulation. Spam policies are meant to stop paid or artificial popularity from pushing better content aside.

Google can ignore artificial links

A bad link does not automatically trigger a penalty. Google may decide the link has no value. Your website then does not benefit from that link, but it does not necessarily drop because of it either. This is a key reason not to blindly disavow every unknown link.

A pattern can lead to a manual action

A human reviewer at Google can decide that a website does not follow the spam policies. In Google Search Console, this appears as a manual action. A part of the website or the whole website may then rank lower or disappear from search results.

For unnatural links pointing to your website, Google wants you to investigate the pattern. First try to remove the links or have them marked properly. Links you cannot remove can be disavowed in the right situation. After that, you can request reconsideration with clear documentation.

Lost artificial value can feel like a drop

A website can benefit for a long time from links that Google later stops counting. When Google ignores that value, organic traffic can fall. That feels like a penalty, but it may simply mean an unfair advantage has disappeared.

That is why a sustainable approach matters. Build content and relationships that remain useful even without manipulative link value. First read what backlinks are and how they can help Google if you are not yet familiar with the normal role of backlinks.

Links from your own website can also be link spam

The risk is not only about incoming links. Do you sell links that pass ranking value, or do you place large numbers of unnatural outgoing links? That can also violate spam policies. For paid placements, use the correct label and be transparent with your visitors.

First, make a clear distinction between a normal review and recovery after a manual action. Without a message and without a history of artificial link building, a calm assessment is usually enough. With a manual action, you need a broader inventory, removal attempts, and clear documentation.

Step 1: check Manual actions in Search Console

Open Google Search Console and view the Manual actions report. Is there no issue listed? Then you do not have a confirmed manual action. Is there a message about unnatural links? Then read carefully whether it affects the whole website or only part of it.

Also check the message center. Save the notice and note the date. Do not change hundreds of things at once without recording what you did and why.

Step 2: gather link data from multiple sources

Export the links to your website in Search Console. Google does not call this a full list of every existing link, but it is an important primary source. Reliable additional SEO tools may find other examples.

Combine the files and remove duplicate rows. Note the source domain, source page, target page, anchor text, first known date, and likely origin. Also add a column for owner or origin. For example: natural, built by us, built by agency, unknown, or hacked.

Step 3: investigate your own history first

Ask who handled SEO in the past. Look for invoices, reports, old emails, and lists of placed links. This is often more useful than looking through thousands of random domains. A paid campaign or a known network can explain a suspicious pattern much faster.

Ask a former agency which links it placed and whether they can still be removed. Keep every response. In a reconsideration request, this documentation shows that you seriously tried to solve the problem.

Step 4: review patterns, not just domains

Look at a sample of the source pages. Does the page have real content and a logical audience? Does the reference fit naturally into the text? Is the anchor text logical? Is the link surrounded by dozens of commercial links? Is there a paid relationship?

Pay special attention to groups of links that appeared around the same time, use the same anchor text, or point to the same commercial page. A pattern of one hundred similar links is usually more important than one odd reference.

Step 5: classify links with evidence

Use three clear categories:

  • Keep: natural, relevant, or editorial links.
  • Investigate: unclear links where context is still missing.
  • Action needed: links that were clearly bought, exchanged, or automatically built to influence rankings.

For each link that needs action, briefly write why it is problematic. “Low score” alone is not a strong reason. “Paid placement by us with commercial anchor text and no sponsored label” is concrete.

Step 6: compare the date with changes

Check in Search Console when traffic and impressions changed. Compare that period with link campaigns, website changes, seasons, and Google updates. Timing does not prove cause, but it helps you focus the research.

A drop in traffic can also happen because of technical problems, weak content, stronger competition, or lower search demand. So do not automatically blame every drop on bad backlinks.

How do you judge three recognizable examples?

Example one is an industry blog that links to your detailed research on its own. The author explains why the data is useful and uses your brand name as anchor text. The domain may be small, but the reference is editorial and voluntary. There is usually no reason to disavow this link.

Example two is an advertorial you paid for. The text contains a commercial anchor text that can pass ranking value. Ask the publisher to label the link properly with rel sponsored or remove the link. The payment and the intent give more information here than a domain score.

Example three is a sudden cluster of hundreds of profile pages with the same anchor text. You do not know the provider, but an old report shows that a previous SEO agency had these profiles created. Investigate the network as one pattern. Where possible, ask for removal and decide on disavowing only according to the official rules.

These examples show why an automated checklist can never make the full decision. The same website can contain a natural editorial link and a paid placement. So always judge the specific page, relationship, and intent.

Which mistakes most often slow down recovery and growth?

Check point How do you check it? Solution Priority
Manual action Manual actions report and messages Investigate the notice, remove violations, and document recovery Critical
Paid links that pass value Invoices, old campaigns, and source pages Remove or label properly Very high
Automated link network Patterns in domains, anchors, and placement dates Try to remove network links and use disavow carefully Very high
Many exact commercial anchors Group the link text by target page Investigate the source and stop artificial placements High
Disavowing every red tool score Check the evidence behind each classification Review the context and origin manually Stop immediately
No proof of removal attempts Check emails and the log Document contact, responses, and outcomes High when there is a manual action
Only working on links after a traffic drop Check technical issues, content, demand, and updates Run a broad diagnosis High
Accidentally disavowing good links Check the disavow file line by line Remove natural domains from the file Critical

Mistake: treating a tool score as a Google penalty

A tool signal is only an indication. The tool does not always know the agreements, payments, or editorial choices behind a link. Check the source and history before taking action.

Mistake: using the disavow tool preventively

Google warns that using it incorrectly can hurt your website’s performance. Most websites do not need it. Use it only when there are many spammy, artificial, or low-quality links and these have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action.

Mistake: not trying to remove links

In a manual action case, Google expects a serious attempt to remove unnatural links. Send polite requests to website owners or to the agency that built the links. Otherwise, ask for rel nofollow or rel sponsored when that is appropriate.

Mistake: trying to make a natural profile too clean

Real link profiles are messy. Not every link uses perfect text or comes from a well-known website. An unnaturally perfect profile can actually point to heavy manipulation. Keep real references, even when they seem to have little value.

Mistake: resuming old link building right after cleanup

Recovery is of little use if the same tactic continues. Stop paid or automated systems. Create clear rules for agencies, partners, and publications. Check contracts before new links are placed.

Priority 1: stop the source of artificial links

Pause campaigns that buy, exchange, or automatically place links. Remove access from unreliable providers. Ask for a full list of previously created links and keep this information in one central place.

Priority 2: fix links you control

Remove unnatural links from your own websites, profiles, and partner pages. Label paid links with rel sponsored. For other non-editorial links, rel nofollow may be appropriate. After every change, check the real HTML of the page.

Priority 3: ask for removal

Contact the owner of the source website. Mention the exact source page and the target URL. Politely ask for removal or proper labeling. Do not simply pay extra money to a dubious website to take a link down. First assess such a request carefully.

Keep a log with the contact date, address, response, and outcome. Send at most one reasonable reminder. Do not waste weeks on websites that do not respond.

Priority 4: decide whether disavowing is really necessary

Use the disavow tool only with great caution. Google says most websites do not need it. It is mainly meant for a significant pattern of artificial links that has caused, or is likely to cause, a manual action.

A disavow file contains one URL or domain per line. For an entire domain, use the format domain:example.com. The tool does not support a Domain property. You must choose the correct URL prefix property. Always check the current official instructions before uploading a file.

Keep a copy of the current file before uploading a new version. A new upload replaces the existing list for that property. So check that every old rule still needed is also included in the new file. You can add comments on lines that start with a hash sign so the source remains clear.

Have a second experienced person review the file. Look especially for real media, partners, suppliers, and industry websites that may have ended up in the list by mistake. A domain-level disavow is broad. One mistake can exclude all links from that domain. So never use an automatically generated file without manual review.

Priority 5: request reconsideration if needed

After recovery from a manual action, submit a reconsideration request. Explain honestly what happened, which links were removed, which links could not be removed, and which measures prevent a repeat. Do not use marketing language. Provide clear and verifiable information.

Priority 6: build a healthy alternative

Create content that deserves real references. Think of original research, useful data, clear free tools, and strong explanations. Reach out to suitable organizations because your source helps their audience, not only because you want a link.

In the explanation of dofollow versus nofollow backlinks, you can read how links fit into a broader SEO approach. Good content, strong technical SEO, a logical internal structure, and real authority work together.

Which checklist and flow can you add as an image?

Create a checklist image with five questions: Is there a manual action? Did we have the link created? Was it paid or exchanged? Can the link be removed? Is disavowing necessary under the official rules?

The flow starts with a suspicious link. Then you collect evidence, assess the context, keep the link or choose an action, try removal, and only at the end use disavow. Add an audit example of a paid placement and a natural mention. Show clearly why one link needs action and the other does not.

Which metric shows whether the improvement is working?

In a manual action case, the status in Search Console is the first clear metric. After a successful request, the action should disappear. That does not mean old rankings will return automatically. Artificial link value may remain gone, and other quality issues may still exist.

Then track relevant impressions and clicks per important page. Compare sufficiently long periods and account for seasonality, competition, and other changes on the website. Do not look only at average position.

Also measure your process progress:

  • The number of demonstrably artificial links that were removed.
  • The number of placements that were labeled properly.
  • The number of unreliable providers you stopped using.
  • The percentage of link actions whose origin was recorded.
  • The number of new natural references to useful content.
  • The status of any manual action.

A falling toxic score in an external tool is not the end goal. The goal is to comply with the policy, stop artificial tactics, and build real value. Check monthly for new unusual patterns, but do not make it a daily source of worry.

Why are toxic backlinks important for SEO?

Google can ignore artificial links. Serious patterns can lead to a manual action. The risk comes mainly from deliberate manipulation, not from every strange link that appears without your permission.

How do I check bad backlinks myself?

First check the Manual actions report in Search Console. Then export the links from Search Console and, if needed, from additional tools. Focus on links that you or an agency had created. Review payment, exchange, automation, anchor text, and editorial context.

Which tool do I need for this?

Google Search Console is the most important official source for notices and a link export. An external tool can show more examples and patterns. Never use only the toxic score from such a tool to make a decision.

How quickly will I see results after removal or disavowal?

Google must recrawl pages and process the data. That can take several weeks. A manual reconsideration also needs processing time. There is no guarantee that old rankings will return.

What is the most common mistake?

The most common mistake is blindly disavowing every unknown or low-rated domain. That can exclude real links unnecessarily. First investigate the history, the reason for the link, and the full pattern.

Can a competitor place bad links to my website?

That is possible, but strange new links do not automatically mean your rankings will drop. Google can ignore many spammy links on its own. Check mainly whether a clear pattern is emerging and whether there is a notice in Search Console. Do not upload a huge disavow file out of fear.

When is help from a specialist useful?

Get help for a manual action, a large old link campaign, or thousands of unclear placements. Choose someone who works carefully, documents evidence, and does not sell new artificial links. Also read what good SEO services should do.

Which SEO action has the highest priority now?

Open Google Search Console today and check the Manual actions report. Is there no notice and have you never had artificial links built? Then do not rush to create a disavow file. Just note any unusual patterns and review them calmly.

Is there a notice, or do you know of an old paid campaign? Then first gather evidence and a full list of those placements. Stop the source, try to remove the links, and record every step. That is a much better first action than blindly blocking thousands of domains.

author-avatar

About Lara Bakker

Lara Bakker is a social media growth specialist at SocialKings with 10 years of experience building and helping grow online profiles. She focuses on visibility, engagement, profile credibility, and growth strategies across platforms such as Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Spotify, Telegram, Discord, and X. Through her work, Lara helps creators, entrepreneurs, and brands better understand how social proof, content performance, and platform signals influence online growth.

Leave a Reply